American Upchuck

Probably the worst American Idol production in their four years. The producers should vote themselves out. One would think with a zillion songs, they could come up with more than three for the Philly sound. I didn't think Idol could mimic Survivor kicking off Janu for ratings. Maybe Carrie was running away with it and they needed to level the playing field. However, they didn't have to pee on the playing field to level it.

Carrie had the best song and the worst song. In both instances she was way more and less than the others. Why in the world did they think her second song was a singable arrangement? It had to have stunk in the practices. And then to have poor Anthony look like he was exploiting a bad situation? Reminded me of WWW wrestling. FIXED!!

Bo must be short for Bo-ring, which is what his first song was. His second song was not loud enough to hear the first half over the background, but he appeared to be singing it OK. Again, Fixed? Vonzell blubbered through her first song. She did better with the second song, but not that much better. Anthony had the most consistant performance. But, he is probably the worst singer, by far. They should have fixed it the week Constantine was voted off. I think he could have easily beaten them all this week.

Carrie gets and A+ and an F-. C?
Bo gets a D+ and a B-. Another C?
Vonzell gets a D and a C+. Still another C?
Anthony gets a B- and a B+. Does that make him the best singer?

Bottom two, if they still count it like last week: Vonzell, Anthony
Going, going, gone: probably Anthony. But I said that last week.